Water-heater repair or replacement comparison
Separate the current failure from the equipment decision. Compare the complete installed outcome—not equipment price alone.
| Decision evidence | Repair path | Replacement path |
|---|---|---|
| Observed symptom and safety status | ||
| Written diagnosis / test evidence | ||
| Age, model, capacity, fuel / energy source | ||
| Parts and labor scope | ||
| Access and related-trade work | ||
| Drainage, venting, electrical, gas, or structural scope | ||
| Permit / inspection responsibility | ||
| Downtime and temporary service | ||
| Disposal / haul-away | ||
| Expected service life evidence | ||
| Labor and material warranty | ||
| Base price / allowances / changes | ||
| Completion and commissioning records |
Safety boundary. Gas odor, combustion concern, electrical hazard, severe leakage, or unsafe access requires the applicable emergency, utility, manufacturer, or qualified-professional route—not a worksheet decision.
Water-heater evidence and installed-scope record
Use exact model and property facts. Leave uncertain technical fields for the appropriate professional.